Arbitration
Montana law provides a framework for resolving wrongful discharge disputes through arbitration. Employers and employees may agree to arbitrate disputes that would otherwise be adjudicated under wrongful discharge provisions, offering a more efficient and less adversarial process than traditional litigation.
Either party may initiate arbitration by making a written offer within 60 days after the filing of a wrongful discharge complaint. The offer must be accepted in writing within 30 days.
A neutral arbitrator must be mutually selected by both parties, or if they cannot agree, the process outlined in Montana law will apply.
Arbitration Process: Arbitration must follow the guidelines established by the Uniform Arbitration Act. However, if there is a conflict between the Uniform Arbitration Act and Montana’s wrongful discharge laws, the latter takes precedence.
Once a valid offer to arbitrate is accepted, arbitration becomes the exclusive remedy for resolving the dispute. The decision made by the arbitrator is final and binding, with the possibility of judicial review under the Uniform Arbitration Act.
If the discharged employee prevails in arbitration, the employer is responsible for paying the arbitrator’s fee and all arbitration costs.
If a party makes a valid offer to arbitrate and the other party rejects it, and the rejecting party subsequently loses in court, the prevailing party may be entitled to reasonable attorney fees incurred after the date of the arbitration offer. This provision incentivizes both parties to consider arbitration seriously as a more cost-effective and less time-consuming method of resolving disputes.
For employers, understanding and properly implementing arbitration clauses in employment contracts or company policies is essential. A customized employee handbook can help you establish clear, fair, and compliant arbitration procedures that align with both state and federal laws.
Our customized employee handbooks are tailored to meet the specific needs of your business, incorporating industry standards, and ensuring compliance with state-specific regulations, including those related to wrongful discharge and arbitration.
For any questions about arbitration procedures, dispute resolution, or updating your employee policies, contact EmployerESource. Our HR experts are ready to help you draft policies that protect your business while promoting a fair and transparent process for resolving employee disputes.
At- Will Employment
Montana is the only state that is not an at-will employment.
Montana law provides clear guidelines regarding wrongful discharge and employee rights upon separation from employment. Under Montana law key definitions are established that help define wrongful termination and the scope of employee rights:
Constructive Discharge refers to a situation where an employee is forced to resign due to intolerable conditions created by the employer, which are so unreasonable that quitting is the only reasonable option. It does not include resignations due to an employer's refusal to promote or improve wages.
Discharge includes all forms of termination, including resignation, layoffs, and job eliminations for legitimate business reasons.
Good Cause for dismissal refers to a legitimate job-related reason such as failure to perform job duties, disruption of business operations, or other valid business reasons.
Fringe Benefits are defined as the employer-paid benefits that apply at the time of termination, including vacation leave, sick leave, and insurance benefits.
Elements of Wrongful Discharge
A discharge can be considered wrongful if:
It is in retaliation for the employee’s refusal to violate public policy or for reporting violations of public policy.
The employee had completed their probationary period and was terminated without good cause.
The employer violated its own written personnel policies.
Employees wrongfully discharged may be entitled to:
Lost Wages and Fringe Benefits: Compensation for lost wages, fringe benefits, and interest, with a cap of 4 years from the date of termination. Interim earnings may be deducted from the amount awarded, along with reasonable expenses incurred while seeking new employment.
Punitive Damages: In cases of fraud or malice by the employer, punitive damages may also be awarded.
However, damages for emotional distress, pain and suffering, or other non-financial losses are not permitted.
Exemptions: Wrongful discharge provisions do not apply to employees covered by federal or state laws prohibiting discharge based on unlawful discrimination or those covered by a collective bargaining agreement or contract of employment.
Limitation of Actions: Employees must file a wrongful discharge action within one year of their termination. If the employer has internal procedures for contesting discharge, the employee must first exhaust these procedures before filing a legal claim.
It’s crucial for employers to ensure their policies are aligned with Montana's wrongful discharge laws. A customized employee handbook can help you address key policies related to employee termination, probation periods, and the proper handling of complaints or disputes.
We offer customized employee handbooks tailored to your industry, state law, and federal regulations. Download yours today to ensure your policies are clear, compliant, and up-to-date.
For any questions or concerns regarding employee relations or wrongful discharge matters, please contact EmployerESource. Our experts are here to provide personalized guidance to help you navigate employment law and HR challenges with confidence.
Final Wages
Under Montana law when an employee separates from employment prior to a scheduled payday, employers must adhere to specific guidelines regarding the payment of unpaid wages.
All unpaid wages are due on the next regular payday for the pay period during which the separation occurred or within 15 days from the date of separation, whichever is earlier. These wages may be paid through regular channels or by mail if the employee requests it.
Theft Allegations and Withholding Wages:
In cases where an employee is discharged due to an allegation of theft, the employer may withhold the wages sufficient to cover the value of the theft under the following conditions:
a. The employee agrees in writing to the withholding; or
b. The employer files a report with the local law enforcement agency within 7 business days of the separation.
If no charges are filed within 30 days, wages are due to the employee. If charges are filed, the court may determine if the withheld wages should be offset by the value of the theft, with possible interest if the employee is found not guilty or if wages were withheld in excess.
To ensure your company is fully compliant with both state and federal wage regulations, including those related to final paychecks, we recommend downloading a customized employee handbook tailored to your state's laws, industry standards, and federal requirements. Our comprehensive handbook service can help you create a policy that protects both your business and your employees.
For questions or concerns regarding employee relations or compliance, don't hesitate to contact EmployerESource. We are here to provide expert guidance on HR matters, helping you navigate the complexities of employment law with confidence.
Garnishments of Pay
Under Montana law, employers are prohibited from discharging or laying off an employee due to an attachment or garnishment served on the employer concerning the employee’s wages. Specifically, Montana law states that no employer shall terminate or suspend an employee’s employment solely because of an attachment or garnishment order against the employee's wages. This law ensures that employees are not penalized or lose their job due to legal financial obligations, offering them important protection.
Montana law mandates that the withholding amount must be sufficient to cover current child support installments. If there are arrearages (unpaid support), the withheld amount must be the greater of:
· The amount necessary to clear the arrearages within 2 years, or
· 25% of the obligor's income.
Additionally, a fee of up to $5 may be withheld monthly by the payor to cover administrative costs associated with each withholding. This ensures that the process remains manageable for both the employer and the employee while meeting legal obligations.
Under Montana law employers are prohibited from discharging, disciplining, or refusing to hire an employee due to a child support obligation or the initiation of income withholding proceedings. This protection ensures that employees are not penalized or discriminated against for fulfilling their child support responsibilities.
It’s essential for employers to ensure that their policies and practices are in compliance with Montana's garnishment and child support withholding laws. A customized employee handbook can provide clear guidance on how to manage these situations, ensuring that your business complies with both state and federal regulations.
For any questions or concerns about employee rights, garnishment, or child support compliance, contact EmployerESource. Our team is ready to assist you in creating compliant, effective policies that protect both your business and your employees.
What do you do?
Take a minute to write an introduction that is short, sweet, and to the point. If you sell something, use this space to describe it in detail and tell us why we should make a purchase. Tap into your creativity. You’ve got this.
What do you do?
Take a minute to write an introduction that is short, sweet, and to the point. If you sell something, use this space to describe it in detail and tell us why we should make a purchase. Tap into your creativity. You’ve got this.